The Thurible Reviews: Ghost - "Popestar"

Ghost aren't so much a band anymore as an unstoppable, unquestionable cultural force—a sort of bizarro Roman Catholic Church in musical form. I think they'd like that comparison. Ghost have been flirting with blasphemy from the very beginning; heck, they even tried to host a concert the same day Pope Francis visited Boston, only shutting it down after they found that the masses of devoted Catholics longing for a glimpse of Frank would so thoroughly clog the city's public transport that Papa's faithful wouldn't make it to his planned anti-Mass. These Nameless Ghouls are showmen (and trolls) through and through. So when Ghost puts out new material, even a short collection of covers, the whole metal world pauses to take a glance.

Ghost may be a larger-than-life musical carnival, but they're still human as well—human enough for a few missteps on the way to their present superstardom. Their last covers EP, If You Have Ghost, was a mixed bag, to say the least. Produced by Dave Grohl (of Dave Grohl fame), it lacked cohesion and often didn't play to the band's strengths, although opener "If You Have Ghosts" was an exceptionally good cover song in every respect and remains a fan favorite. Popestar is a much stronger work overall, but not without a few of the same mistakes and missteps from Ghost's last mostly-covers effort.

"Squared Hammer," Popestar's only original cut, is sugary even by Ghost's standards. With a tight standard song structure and a sing-along chorus, it's a definite step away from the progressive tendencies Ghost displayed on Meliora. It's a not a bad song, but it's solidly B-side or bonus track material. If "Squared Hammer" is, as many suspect, a leftover track from Meliora that didn't make the cut, Papa and the Ghouls make the right call in saving it for what is, let's be honest, a throwaway EP to tide fans over until Ghost's next full-length.

The next three tracks are much stronger. Ghost thrives on the ominous melodies and triple meter of Echo & The Bunnymen's "Nocturnal Me," transforming the original's gothy waltz into a doomy showcase of Papa's sinister charisma. "I Believe" delivers a stripped-down re-imagining of the 2007 minor house music hit, changing the thumping club song into a haunting hymn that's undeniably Ghost. Once again, Papa's vocals take center stage. "Missionary Man" cleaves closest to the style and feel of the original Eurythmics track, down to the country twang and harmonica solo. It's certainly an odd song for Ghost to put a spin on (and put a spin on it they do), but I guess self-proclaimed sex symbol Papa Emeritus III couldn't pass up on the chance to channel actual sex symbol Annie Lennox.

Closer "Bible" is the weakest number of the bunch. Although Ghost's decision to cover the work of fellow Swedes Imperiet isn't at all surprising, their choice to cover the American version of Imperiet's "Bible" is perplexing to say the least. The original Swedish version of the song is lush alternative anthem—a bit heavy on 80s Europeanisms, but a fine song nonetheless. The American version is an utterly forgettable glam rock power ballad, indistinguishable from hundreds of tracks just like it that vied for radio play in the late 80s and early 90s. Even worse, Ghost's interpretation brings nothing to the track aside from modern studio tricks and a fuller sound. Heck, it's barely recognizable as a Ghost song, apart from Papa's slight accent on the verses. It's a disappointing close to an EP that will probably please both casual listeners and fanatical Ghost fans like me, even with its flaws.

Recommended.

The Thurible's Top 10 Metal Albums of 2015

1. Obsequiae - Aria of Vernal Tombs

It takes a lot for a band in an overcrowded genre like black metal to carve out a sound so distinct that they're instantly recognizable, and even more for that band to move beyond an attention grabbing gimmick to a complete sound. Yet Obsequiae's Aria of Vernal Tombs does both. Combining gorgeous harp interludes with medieval black metal melodies, this album transports the listener to moss-covered ruins and abandoned monastery gardens on the wings of its delicate riffs. Much like Panopticon's Roads to the North did a year ago, this album blew me away with it originality, mastery, and evocative quality. Aria of Vernal Tombs truly is a journey to ages past.

Favorite Track: "In the Absence of Light"

2. Ghost - Meliora

This is it. This is the defining metal act of our generation. Combining doomy hard rock with new-found progressive sensibilities and the same goofy shtick they've been rocking since day one, Meliora finally perfects these Swedish enigmas' formula and delivers one insidious earworm after another. From the triumphant "Spirit" to the equally exultant "Deus In Absentia," Ghost never miss a beat. Whoever Ghost are (I'm not saying some of them show up on this list again, but Tribulation sure sound Ghost-y at times), it's about time the music lived up to the legend. Hail Papa.

Favorite Track: "From the Pinnacle to the Pit"

3. Panopticon - Autumn Eternal

Austin Lunn of Panopticon concludes his three-album love affair with the vast solitude of the Kentucky wilderness in majestic form. On track after track, Lunn captures the beauty and loneliness of dense mountain woods, black lakes and distant white peaks. While Autumn Eternal lacks the bluegrass instrumentation so prominent in Panopticon previous two albums, the rich, post-rock influenced atmospheres are a very welcome addition. As American black metal continues to develop, Autumn Eternal will likely become a touchstone for bands that unite beautiful post-metal melodies with Norwegian black metal's celebration of frost-covered forests glistening on a late autumn night.

Favorite Track: "Into the North Woods"

4. Dead to a Dying World - Litany

It's rare that black or doom metal feels like a work of genius. After all, heavy metal is an unapologetically derivative genre–deeply committed to paying homage and meeting expectations. And while this means that a good black or doom metal band can deliver a dozen solid albums in career, works that completely floor the listener are hard to come by.

That's what makes Litany so special–it's emotional, visceral, masterfully composed, beautifully performed, and most importantly, highly original. There's not a minute of filler on this momentous work, despite its lengthy songs and numerous instrumental passages. Don't let this metal masterpiece pass you by.

Favorite Track: "Eventide"

5. Myrkur - M

I can't deny that Myrkur's first proper album is amateurish at times–some of the transitions are still awkward, and the screamed vocals buried under heaps of distortion and reverb grate just as much as they did on her debut. Yet Myrkur's inexperience is united to an earnestness and a genuine talent for crafting gorgeous atmospheres and melodies that no other black metal band comes close to capturing. Unlike many self-professed "folk" metal bands, Myrkur's integration of Danish carols into black metal feels completely natural, and unlike many recent post-black metal albums, the M doesn't feel like it's being made beautiful against its will. Let the kvltists weep–this Danish model makes more interesting black metal than most scene veterans, and it can only get better from here.

Favorite Track: "Onde Børn"

6. Tribulation - The Children of the Night

The Children of the Night is Tribulation's answer to a black and death metal scene that's forgotten how to make rock music. Like fellow Scandinavian black 'n' rollers Kvelertak, Tribulation infuse their aggressive sound with punk energy and big hooks, producing extreme metal that's surprisingly listenable and even fun. Unlike Kvelertak, however, Tribulation still deliver plenty of black metal menace and theatrics (not unlike another spooky Swedish band that made this list) with their evident love of classic horror and church organs. Heavy metal you can hum along to is back from the dead.

Favorite Track: "Melancholia"

7. Windhand - Grief's Eternal Flower

I'm embarrassed by how little time I spent listening to this album this year, but what few listens I squeezed in left a huge impression. As the 2010s doom metal revival and corresponding hipster fascination with the genre appears to be winding down, Grief's Eternal Flower likely represents the best of doom metal to come–slow, crunchy, and heavy on melody. There's nothing particularly innovative about Windhand, but this album encapsulates all the best elements of the doom revival, from the haunting vocals to the lumbering drum marches and bluesy riffs. In the year of uplifting black metal, doom got even more gloomy.

Favorite Track: "Forest Clouds"

8. Liturgy - The Ark Work

I really, really wanted to hate this album. It's pretentious, pompous, self-important music made by pretentious, pompous, self-important people for a pretentious, pompous, self-important listening public.

Turns out I'm pretentious, pompous, and self-important too, because I can't stop listening to this ungodly smörgåsbord of trendy hipster tripe.

Favorite track: "Reign Away"

9. Elder - Lore

I've heard Elder described as what you would get if prog band from the seventies had been introduced to Mastodon by a meddling time traveler. It's not a bad comparison–Elder combine modern stoner rock's penchant for rugged riffage with the innovation and ponderous song constructions of 70s prog. By injecting high-energy heavy metal into prog rock's meandering opuses, Elder makes their 10-minute apiece songs surprisingly approachable and brings a much needed straightforwardness to a genre notorious for what is essentially musical wankery. There's still plenty of shredding and possibly drug-induced weirdness, but it comes in a package fans of both Rush and Pallbearer should appreciate.

Favorite Track: "Compendium"

10. Ghost Bath - Moonlover

So Ghost Bath's "depressive black metal band from Chongqing" turned out to be a mix of branding and black metal blogs getting carried away. So what? These North Dakotans (spoiler alert) still play some of the best post-black metal around, and Moonlover is a step up from their already excellent debut. If a good sophomore album is more of the same (but better), Moonlover hits all the right notes: more bittersweet melodies, more desperation, more lonely interludes, and much better shrieks–the only major weakness on Funeral. Don't dismiss this controversial act–they're more than Deafheaven in yellowface.

Favorite Track: "Golden Number"